3Commas Alternative: Trigr vs 3Commas and Cryptohopper

Looking for a 3Commas alternative for perps? A fair comparison of Trigr, 3Commas and Cryptohopper on bot types, backtesting, AI and Hyperliquid.

Trigr ResearchUpdated 7 min read
On this page
  1. What do 3Commas and Cryptohopper actually do?
  2. How is Trigr different?
  3. Side-by-side comparison
  4. How do the backtests compare?
  5. How do they handle keys and custody?
  6. What about AI?
  7. When is 3Commas or Cryptohopper the better choice?
  8. When is Trigr the better choice?
  9. Next steps

TL;DR: 3Commas and Cryptohopper are mature, multi-exchange bot platforms built around ready-made bot types such as DCA, grid and signal bots (plus copy bots on Cryptohopper), with templates and presets that help beginners get started. Trigr is a different kind of tool: you build or generate custom strategies for Hyperliquid perps, test them with point-in-time backtests that separate gross from net, and run them as non-custodial agents. If you want a DCA or grid bot on a centralized exchange, 3Commas or Cryptohopper will fit better; if you want to research and run perp strategies on Hyperliquid, Trigr is designed for that.

What do 3Commas and Cryptohopper actually do?

Both are cloud platforms that connect to your exchange accounts through API keys and run automated bots on your behalf. Their strength is breadth: many exchanges, many bot styles and a large set of presets.

3Commas is organized around bot types. Its pricing page lists DCA bots, grid bots and signal bots, with plan tiers named Starter, Pro and Expert. As of September 2026, billed monthly, Starter ($20) covers spot trading on one exchange, Pro ($50) adds spot and futures trading on up to five exchanges, and Expert ($140) raises the limits further and adds read-and-write developer API access. All three plans list a demo account and Pine Script execution.

Cryptohopper is organized around a configurable trading bot (a "hopper"), plus copy bots, market-making and arbitrage bots. Its pricing page lists Explorer ($29 per month), Adventurer ($69 per month) and Hero ($129 per month) when billed monthly, with a three-day free trial, as of September 2026. Paper trading, backtesting, the strategy designer, marketplace access and copy bots are listed on every tier; arbitrage starts at Adventurer, and market-making, AI strategies and the AI designer are part of Hero.

How is Trigr different?

Trigr does not offer preset bot types. You build a strategy as a graph: exactly one trigger, optional filters, a signal, a risk block and execution. The copilot can draft that graph from plain English, or you can build it from ChatGPT, Claude or Codex through Trigr's MCP server.

What you gain is range in the logic itself. Any node can read a different asset, and the data sources go beyond price: funding rate, open interest, long/short ratio, liquidations, DVOL, on-chain and social data, FRED macro series, VIX, CFTC COT, EIA oil stocks and more. The post on funding-rate and open-interest strategies shows the kind of rules this makes possible.

What you give up is breadth of venue. Trigr agents run on Paper, Hyperliquid or Propr only. There are 43 certified crypto perps on Hyperliquid, and TradFi perps via HIP-3 (gold, the S&P 500, NVDA and others) that can be backtested and run on paper agents only in the current beta.

Side-by-side comparison

Competitor details below come from each vendor's official pricing and help pages and are accurate as of September 2026.

Topic 3Commas Cryptohopper Trigr
Core model Preset bot types (DCA, grid, signal) Configurable trading bot, plus copy, market-making and arbitrage bots Custom strategy graph or ML model
Venues Many centralized exchanges (see its supported-exchange list) Many exchanges (see its docs) Paper, Hyperliquid, Propr
Backtesting DCA bot backtests on 1-minute candles Backtester for template and bot settings, with some exclusions Point-in-time backtests with DSR, PBO and audit trail
Costs in backtests Total fees shown in results Optional start amount and maker/taker fee Fees always on; slippage and funding opt-in, gross labeled
Paper or demo Demo account on all plans Paper trading bot Paper agents
AI AI Assistant that creates and backtests DCA bot strategies AI strategies and AI designer (Hero); read-only market-data MCP Copilot, plus your own assistant over MCP
Marketplace Not covered in the pages cited Signals, strategies and bot templates from approved sellers Immutable, versioned strategies with verified backtests
Pricing (billed monthly) $20 Starter, $50 Pro, $140 Expert $29 Explorer, $69 Adventurer, $129 Hero Free, $29 Trader, $99 Pro

How do the backtests compare?

This is the most useful place to look closely, because each platform tests a different kind of object.

3Commas

3Commas backtests DCA bot configurations. Its DCA bot backtesting guide says only 1-minute candle data is available, that the backtest waits for a candle to close and simulates the trade at the close price of the next 1-minute candle, and that entry and averaging prices may differ slightly from live trading. You can choose the test period, which is useful for checking a setup across bull, bear and sideways phases. The help center also describes an AI Assistant, powered by Google's Gemini models, that creates and backtests strategies from chat, and notes that it currently only creates and backtests DCA bot strategies.

Cryptohopper

Cryptohopper's documentation on how to use the Backtester says it can test template and bot settings except triggers, built-in strategies and TradingView alerts, and lets you set a start amount and a maker/taker fee percentage, over a date range of up to one month. The same page states that this Backtester is currently available exclusively to Marketplace Sellers, while the pricing page lists backtesting on every tier, so check which version applies to your account.

Trigr

Trigr backtests the exact strategy you will deploy, with fixed conventions: point-in-time data, fills at the next bar's open, the stop wins if take-profit and stop-loss are both touched in one bar, and trading plus builder fees always applied. Slippage (your flat bps per fill) and funding (historical or a flat per-8h rate) are opt-in, and the first result is labeled gross. The post on slippage and funding in perp backtests explains why the net view matters on perps, where funding is a real cash flow.

A standard backtest reports net return, raw Sharpe, drawdown, a robustness score and an Overfit risk badge that compares the Sharpe with what luck alone could reach after the strategy's tries; an ML optimization run adds its own Deflated Sharpe Ratio over the models it compared and the Probability of Backtest Overfitting. A standard backtest costs 50 credits and uses full available history. Backtests are not guarantees; perps are leveraged and can lose more than expected.

How do they handle keys and custody?

All three platforms trade on an account you own rather than taking deposits themselves. 3Commas and Cryptohopper connect to centralized exchanges through exchange API keys that you create and grant trading permissions.

On Hyperliquid, Trigr uses a trade-only agent key, which Hyperliquid calls an API wallet. It can place and cancel orders but cannot withdraw. For autonomous agents, Trigr stores that trade-only key encrypted server-side, while you keep your master wallet key and custody of funds. The explainer on Hyperliquid agent wallets covers the model and its limits, including the roughly 90-day key validity.

What about AI?

All three now offer AI features, in different shapes. 3Commas has an AI Assistant for DCA bots. Cryptohopper offers AI strategies on its Hero plan and documents a Market Data MCP server that exposes order book, ticker and candle data to MCP-compatible clients; its documentation describes that server as read-only, with no trade execution or account changes.

Trigr's MCP server is focused on strategy research and management: an assistant can search the capability catalog, draft and save strategies, run credit-metered backtests with optional slippage and funding, read stored runs and full trade logs for free, launch ML optimization, publish eligible strategies and create a paused paper agent. It cannot start execution, place live trades, withdraw or touch credentials, and each consequential action uses a ten-minute, single-use authorization bound to the exact arguments. The guide to AI trading agent safety walks through the approval modes.

When is 3Commas or Cryptohopper the better choice?

Be honest about fit. One of the established bot platforms is likely better if:

  • You trade on centralized exchanges. Both support many exchanges; Trigr supports Paper, Hyperliquid and Propr only.
  • You want DCA or grid bots. DCA features are central to both platforms, and 3Commas also lists grid bots on every plan. Trigr does not offer averaging-down ladders or grids.
  • You trade spot. Trigr is built for perpetual futures.
  • You want copy trading or signal subscriptions today. Cryptohopper documents copy bots and a signals marketplace. Trigr does not offer copy trading, and external signal providers are not available yet.
  • You want a large preset library to start from. Templates and presets reduce setup time considerably.

When is Trigr the better choice?

Trigr fits better if:

  • You trade Hyperliquid perps and want strategies that use funding, open interest, liquidations or macro data.
  • You want backtests that state their assumptions plainly and separate gross from net.
  • You want ML models validated with purged walk-forward testing and leak checks rather than tuned to a backtest.
  • You want to run up to 52 strategies, one per market, in one agent, as described in multi-strategy agents.
  • You prefer to work through ChatGPT, Claude or Codex with explicit limits on what they can do.

Next steps

For a broader view of how Trigr's backtests differ from other tools, start with the TradingView Strategy Tester comparison, then browse verified strategies in the marketplace and forward-test one on a paper agent before risking capital.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between Trigr and 3Commas?

3Commas is built around configurable bot types such as DCA, grid and signal bots across many centralized exchanges. Trigr is built around custom rule-based or ML strategies for Hyperliquid perps, tested with point-in-time backtests and deployed as paper, Hyperliquid or Propr agents.

Is Cryptohopper or 3Commas better for beginners?

Both offer ready-made bot templates, demo or paper modes and large help centers, which suits beginners who want to automate familiar approaches like DCA. The right one depends on your exchange and the bot style you want; check each vendor's current plans and exchange list.

Does Trigr have DCA or grid bots?

No. Trigr strategies are built from a trigger, filters, a signal and a risk block, with take-profit, stop-loss, ATR trailing and time stops. It does not offer averaging-down DCA ladders or grid bots.

Can Trigr trade on Binance or Bybit?

No. Trigr agents run on one of three venues: Paper, Hyperliquid or Propr. If you need centralized exchanges such as Binance or Bybit, a multi-exchange bot platform is a better fit.

Put the idea to an honest test.

Describe a strategy in plain English or from your own AI assistant, backtest it on point-in-time data, and forward-test it on paper before any real money is involved.