The Fear & Greed index just hit 11, and crypto Twitter says this is where you buy. We went back and checked every time the index fell this low since 2018. Three months later, Bitcoin was up only 8 times out of 17, and the typical trade was down 8%. Buying on a random day did better. But a second signal is flashing right now, and that one has a perfect record. Verdict: buying extreme fear is a fade. Bitcoin below its 200-week line has been a buy every time so far.
The claim
The post came from @TaekwonV82 on X and passed 42,700 views: Bitcoin just printed its sixth red week in a row, and Fear & Greed is at 11. The idea behind posts like this is simple. When everyone is scared, prices are low, so you buy.
It sounds like common sense. So we tested it.
How we tested it
| Setting | Value |
|---|---|
| Signal | Crypto Fear & Greed index at 15 or below |
| New signal | Only after 30 days without one, so one panic counts once |
| Signals found | 17, from February 2018 to June 2026 |
| Measure | Bitcoin price 3 months after the signal |
| Compared with | Buying on a random day, held for 3 months |
| Second signal | Weekly close below the 200-week average, held for 1 year, since 2015 (Bitstamp weekly closes) |
Extreme fear: the results
| Signal | Bitcoin price | 3 months later |
|---|---|---|
| 2 Feb 2018 | $8,873 | +9.5% |
| 30 Mar 2018 | $6,840 | -9.4% |
| 11 Jun 2018 | $6,872 | -8.1% |
| 6 Sep 2018 | $6,517 | -46.2% |
| 21 Nov 2018 | $4,661 | -14.8% |
| 6 Feb 2019 | $3,407 | +75.7% |
| 14 Aug 2019 | $10,055 | -12.7% |
| 25 Sep 2019 | $8,430 | -14.5% |
| 18 Dec 2019 | $7,278 | -25.9% |
| 12 Mar 2020 | $4,800 | +93.3% |
| 20 May 2021 | $40,525 | +15.4% |
| 6 Jan 2022 | $43,082 | +0.8% |
| 9 May 2022 | $30,074 | -20.8% |
| 27 Feb 2025 | $84,709 | +24.7% |
| 13 Nov 2025 | $99,692 | -33.5% |
| 1 Feb 2026 | $76,968 | +2.1% |
| 3 Jun 2026 | $64,143 | +20.6% |
| Extreme fear vs a random day | 3 months later |
|---|---|
| Signals that were up | 8 of 17 |
| Typical result, extreme fear | -8.1% |
| Typical result, random day | +3.6% |
Two signals did most of the work: March 2020 (+93%) and February 2019 (+76%). Take those out and the picture gets worse. The index hit the same level in November 2025, with Bitcoin near $100,000. A year later it was around $64,000.
The fear also tends to come early. The lowest weekly close in the year after a signal came a median of 26 weeks later, and around 37% below the signal price. Only 2 of the 17 signals were close to the actual bottom.
Why extreme fear is a weak signal on its own
The Fear & Greed index mixes price swings, trading volume, social media mood and a few other inputs into one number from 0 to 100. A low number tells you people are scared right now. It does not tell you how far a sell-off still has to run.
That is the problem with buying it. Fear often shows up at the start of a drop, not at the end. In 2018 the index fell to extreme fear five times while Bitcoin kept sliding from $8,800 to $3,400. In 2022 it happened again in January and May, and the real low came months later, after the FTX collapse.
The 200-week line works differently. It does not measure mood. It measures how far the price has fallen against its own four-year average. When Bitcoin closes below that line, it has usually been falling for a long time already, and most sellers are gone.
The second signal: the 200-week line
The 200-week moving average is the average of Bitcoin's last 200 weekly closes, about four years of prices. Bitcoin rarely closes below it. Last week it did: about $65,300 against a line near $68,000.
| Below the 200-week line | Weekly closes | Typical result 1 year later |
|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 5 | +158% |
| 2020 (March crash) | 1 | +1,004% |
| 2022 to 2023 | 46 | +113% |
| All since 2015 | 52 | +121%, worst +18% |
Every one of the 52 weekly closes below the line was higher a year later. Four recent closes, including last week's, are less than a year old and are not counted yet.
The verdict
Extreme fear on its own: fade it. It is a coin flip that leans the wrong way, and a random day did better.
The 200-week line: so far it has been a buy every time. The catch is the sample: 52 weeks sounds like a lot, but they come from only three bear markets. And "higher a year later" does not mean "the bottom is in". In 2022 Bitcoin stayed under the line for 46 weeks before it turned.
What to watch now
- The current fear signal started on 14 November 2026. If history repeats, the low would come between mid February and late August 2027, with mid May in the middle.
- Bitcoin is already below the 200-week line.
- The halving buy window, 500 days before the next halving, opens around 28 November to 8 December 2026. We tested that rule in our halving post.
You can see how we label backtests, paper and live results on our transparency page, and how testing works in the Trigr docs.
Past results do not predict future results. This is research, not a live strategy. Not trading advice.