S&P 500 After Midterms: Is the 21 Out of 21 Claim True?

A viral chart says the S&P 500 rose from November to June after all 21 midterms since 1942. We tested the windows since 2010 with fees against just holding.

April Zoe4 min read
On this page
  1. The viral claim
  2. How we rebuilt it in Trigr
  3. The four midterm windows
  4. But here is the thing
  5. Strategy vs just holding
  6. Why base rates matter
  7. What we would test next
  8. Verdict: trade it or fade it?
  9. Try it yourself

A viral chart says the S&P 500 went up from November to June after every midterm election since 1942: 21 out of 21. We tested it on our data since 2010. All four midterm windows went up, but in normal years the same window was up 82% of the time anyway, and holding only the midterm windows made +41% versus +576% for just holding. Verdict: trade it as one bet for one window, not as a strategy.

The viral claim

The chart, with more than 300,000 views, lists every midterm year since 1942 and the S&P 500's return from November to June after it. Every single one is positive: 21 out of 21. With a midterm election just behind us, a lot of people want to know if they should buy now.

21 out of 21 sounds like a law of nature. It is worth asking two questions. Does it hold in recent data? And is it really about midterms, or about stocks in general?

See the original chart on X.

The viral chart: S&P 500 up from November to June after 21 of 21 midterms since 1942

How we rebuilt it in Trigr

Our S&P 500 data in Trigr starts in 2010, which gives us four midterms to test.

Setting Value
Market S&P 500
Rule In a midterm year, buy in November
Exit Sell at the end of June
Window November 2010 to June 2023, then compared with holding to 2026
Costs Fees and slippage included

The four midterm windows

Midterm Window S&P 500 return
2010 Nov 2010 to Jun 2011 +11.0%
2014 Nov 2014 to Jun 2015 +2.3%
2018 Nov 2018 to Jun 2019 +8.9%
2022 Nov 2022 to Jun 2023 +13.9%

Every midterm since 2010, November to June, S&P 500 with fees

So yes, all four went up. In our window the claim holds: 4 out of 4.

But here is the thing

We ran the same November to June window in every other year since 2010.

November to June, S&P 500 since 2010 Up
After midterms 4 of 4 (100%)
Normal years 82%

After midterms 4 of 4 windows were up, normal years 82% of the time

In normal years, November to June was up 82% of the time anyway. Midterms helped a little, but mostly stocks just go up. A rule that wins 100% of the time when the base rate is 82% has a small edge, and four data points are not enough to prove even that.

Strategy vs just holding

Since 2010 Return Trades Worst drop
Only midterm windows +41% 4 -16.5%
Just holding the S&P 500 +576% 1

Since 2010: only midterm windows +41% vs +576% for just holding the S&P 500

If you only held during the midterm windows, you would be up about +41% since 2010. Just holding the whole time made over +570%. The midterm rule sits in cash most of the time, and in a market that mostly goes up, cash is expensive.

Why base rates matter

The most useful question to ask about any pattern is: compared with what? A 100% hit rate sounds amazing until you learn that the normal rate is 82%. The midterm effect is the gap between those two numbers, not the 100% on its own.

Small samples make this harder. Four midterms is very little data. Even the 21 windows since 1942 are only 21 data points, spread across very different markets. With so few cases, a pattern can look perfect by chance, especially when the underlying asset goes up most of the time anyway.

There is also a cost that a hit rate does not show: the time you spend out of the market. A rule that is only invested for eight months every four years misses most of the gains in between. That is why the strategy made +41% while holding made over +570%. When you test seasonal or event patterns, always compare them with simply holding the same market over the same period.

What we would test next

Two follow-ups would make this test stronger. First, a longer history: our data starts in 2010, so a source going back to 1942 would let us check all 21 windows with fees. Second, the size of the edge: comparing the average November to June return after midterms with the average in other years tells you whether the midterm windows were simply up, or up by more than usual.

Verdict: trade it or fade it?

Trade it, but as one bet for one window. It is not a strategy. History says the window after a midterm has been good, and it has never failed in the data. But the same window is usually good in any year, and staying out the rest of the time costs far more than the midterm edge gives you.

This is a classic example of a pattern that is true and still not very useful. For more on separating real edges from noise, read our guide to backtest overfitting warning signs and why backtests and live results differ.

Try it yourself

You can test calendar rules like this one in Trigr and compare them with just holding in a few minutes. Start from the docs. This is a research article: the calendar rule is not listed as a strategy.

Sources: the viral chart on X, Fidelity on US midterm elections and stocks and S&P Dow Jones Indices on the S&P 500.

Backtest, not live. S&P 500 daily, 2010 to 2026, fees and slippage included. Research only. Past results are not a promise of future results, and this is not financial advice.

Frequently asked questions

Has the S&P 500 really gone up after every midterm?

The viral chart counts 21 of 21 November to June windows since 1942. In our data since 2010, all four midterm windows were up: +11%, +2.3%, +8.9% and +13.9%.

Is the midterm effect special?

Only a little. Since 2010, the same November to June window was up 82% of the time in normal years too, because stocks mostly go up.

Should you only invest in midterm windows?

No. Holding only those windows made about +41% since 2010. Just holding the S&P 500 the whole time made about +576%.

Can this be run as a strategy on Trigr?

It is research only: it is tested on market data with a calendar rule and can be used as one bet for one window, not as an ongoing strategy.

Put the idea to an honest test.

Describe a strategy in plain English or from your own AI assistant, backtest it on point-in-time data, and forward-test it on paper before any real money is involved.