MACD trading strategies: backtest vs live results

MACD is the gap between a fast and a slow exponential moving average, with a signal line. Strategies trade its crosses and the turn of its histogram.

101 published strategies, 81 of them built by Trigr. Each one has its own page, where its backtest and its live paper record are shown separately when it has them. Of the 79 with 14 or more days of live paper record, 38 are up (median 0.0%, average +0.3%, over a median 44 days). In backtest, 101 of 101 were up (median +72.7%, average +149.9%). The average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it. A backtest covers years and a live record covers weeks, so the two returns are not the same length of time.

101 strategies
In backtest
101of 101 up
Median backtest return +72.7%, average +149.9%, over the years each backtest covers.
Live paper record · 14+ days
38of 79 up
Median live return 0.0%, average +0.3%, over a median 44 days. 3 flat at 0%, 38 down.

The median is the middle return. The average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it.

Backtest against live, strategy by strategy

One dot per strategy with 14 or more live days: how good its backtest looked, against what it has done since. A higher backtest Sharpe went weakly with a better live result here (rank correlation 0.17, where 0 means no link and 1 a perfect one). 1 record beyond the plotted range sits on its edge.

Live paper return
−50%−25%0%+25%+50%
Up liveDown live
00.511.522.53
Backtest Sharpe ratio

Live returns

How the 79 live paper returns are spread. Each record runs from the day its strategy was published, so they cover different lengths of time.

3
2
11
12
10
3
17
9
4
4
4
−20%−10%−5%−2%0%2%5%10%20%
UpFlat (0%)Down

Backtest and live results by indicator

Each row counts the strategies of one group: how many are up in backtest, and how many of those with a live record are up, flat or down since. The median is the middle return; the average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it.

Indicator
EMA31
11 of 22 (50%)
+0.1%+1.9%
SMA19
4 of 13 (31%)
−1.1%+3.0%
ADX17
13 of 15 (87%)
+0.2%+3.3%
RSI17
3 of 5 (60%)
+0.8%+5.3%
Parabolic SAR11
8 of 9 (89%)
+0.2%−0.7%
Z-Score9
none yet
n/an/a
Funding Rate8
4 of 8 (50%)
+0.3%+0.8%
Bollinger Bands5
2 of 5 (40%)
0.0%+2.0%
Hurst Exponent3
2 of 3
+0.6%−0.7%
ATR2
0 of 2
−5.6%−5.6%
UpFlat (0%)Down

Does a stronger backtest hold up live?

Grouped by the Sharpe ratio of the backtest: does the better-looking group do better live? A higher backtest Sharpe went weakly with a better live result here (rank correlation 0.17, where 0 means no link and 1 a perfect one).

Backtest SharpeStrategiesUp liveMedian liveAvg live
under 0.516
4 of 16 (25%)
−2.8%−2.6%
0.5 to 149
21 of 43 (49%)
0.0%+2.0%
1 to 1.522
5 of 9 (56%)
+6.2%+1.2%
1.5 to 23
0 of 2
−16.7%−16.7%
2 and over11
8 of 9 (89%)
+0.2%+0.1%

Up live by market and timeframe

Where the live records are up, and where they are not, for the largest groups.

1H4HDaily
HYPE8/11
Ethereum3/55/7
STX51
ADA22
JUP22
PEPE4
ARB21
ENA3
Google21
NEAR21
Share up live0%100%A cell reads up live / with 14+ live days. Grey cells have fewer than 5 live records and show their strategy count.

All 101 MACD strategies

Longest live record first, not best return first. Select a column to sort by it; open a strategy for its full record.

ADA Trend Rider · Daily
ADA · Daily · Long only
+32.7%0.50−3.8%115
Bitcoin Adaptive Momentum · Daily
BTC · Daily · Long only
+206.2%1.08+16.8%115
Bitcoin Momentum · Daily
BTC · Daily · Long only
+40.6%0.99+2.5%115
Ethereum Bitcoin-MACD Breakout · 4H
ETH · 4H · Long only
+101.3%1.20+6.2%115
Ethereum Dip Buyer · Daily
ETH · Daily · Long/short
+4.3%0.510.0%115
Ethereum Fast Momentum · Daily
ETH · Daily · Long/short
+105.8%0.75+15.5%115
Ethereum MA Momentum · 4H
ETH · 4H · Long/short
+201.7%1.18+23.0%115
Ethereum MACD Momentum · Daily
ETH · Daily · Long only
+36.6%0.82+5.5%115
Ethereum Momentum · Daily
ETH · Daily · Long only
+56.9%0.58+16.6%115
Ethereum Short-Hold Momentum · 4H
ETH · 4H · Long/short
+53.2%0.81+6.3%115
Ethereum Slow Momentum · Daily
ETH · Daily · Long only
+69.0%0.70−2.6%115
Ethereum Strict Breakout · 4H
ETH · 4H · Long only
+838.8%1.43−3.2%115
Ethereum Trailing Momentum · Daily
ETH · Daily · Long/short
+281.8%0.94+36.5%115
Ethereum Uncrowded Momentum · Daily
ETH · Daily · Long only
+120.2%1.16+8.1%115
INJ Bitcoin-MACD Momentum · Daily
INJ · Daily · Long only
+8.8%0.28−4.6%115
JUP Downtrend Short · Daily
JUP · Daily · Long only
+8.9%0.82+0.7%115
JUP Downtrend Short · Daily
JUP · Daily · Long only
+8.9%0.82+0.6%115
LDO Downtrend Short · Daily
LDO · Daily · Long only
+8.5%0.61−3.5%115
ONDO Momentum · Daily
ONDO · Daily · Long only
+7.9%0.39+0.6%115
TIA Breakout · Hourly
TIA · 1H · Long only
+12.2%0.40−4.2%115
VVV Bitcoin-MACD Breakout · 4H
VVV · 4H · Long only
+57.9%1.39+11.0%115
ZRO Momentum · Daily
ZRO · Daily · Long only
+6.9%0.49+1.0%115
Google Momentum · Hourly
GOOGL · 1H · Long only
+22.3%0.37−2.7%107
Micron Momentum · Hourly
MU · 1H · Long only
+18.6%0.35+1.3%107
Micron Slow Momentum · Hourly
MU · 1H · Long only
+38.6%0.36−6.2%107
Tesla Momentum · Daily
TSLA · Daily · Long only
+79.7%0.76−0.3%106
Gold Tight-Stop Momentum · Daily
GOLD · Daily · Long only
+10.9%0.50+0.8%105
Google Slow Momentum · Hourly
GOOGL · 1H · Long only
+11.4%0.33−2.7%105
Nvidia Trailing Multi-Signal · Daily
NVDA · Daily · Long/short
+28.8%0.59−0.5%105
ADA MACD Cycle 4H v2 — 20% at 2x
ADA · 4H · Long/short
+601.9%0.96−11.1%70
HYPE MACD Cycle 4H v1 — 100% at 1x
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+336.9%1.71−31.8%70
ICP MACD Cycle 4H v2 — 50% at 1x
ICP · 4H · Long/short
+257.8%0.91−20.4%70
JUP MACD Cycle 4H v1 — 50% at 1x
JUP · 4H · Long/short
+215.5%1.07−33.8%70
NEAR MACD Cycle 1D v1 — 20% at 2x
NEAR · Daily · Long/short
+327.2%0.75+59.0%70
STX MACD Cycle 4H v1 — 50% at 1x
STX · 4H · Long/short
+220.3%0.89−18.8%70
TRUMP MACD Cycle 4H v1 — 50% at 1x
TRUMP · 4H · Long/short
+16.5%0.44−1.4%70
WLD MACD Cycle 4H v1 — 20% at 2x
WLD · 4H · Long/short
+209.5%0.95−8.4%70
HYPE 15m/1H Trend-Pullback Long
HYPE · 4H · Long only
+10.5%2.10−1.2%49
HYPE - Apex Max SAR III SO30
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+2630.0%2.60+1.0%44
Moonshot PEPE SAR III sz5 10x SL5
1000PEPE · 4H · Long only
+262.4%1.24−8.1%44
HR26 HYPE Tide 10%x10 (src 2a903d28)
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+285.1%2.47+0.2%41
HYPE - Apex Tide SAR III sz10
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+105.7%2.45+0.2%41
HYPE Tide SAR III sz10 · CORE5
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+105.7%2.45+0.2%41
HYPE Tide SAR III sz10 · Q
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+105.7%2.45+0.2%41
HYPE Tide SAR III sz10 · TILT
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+105.7%2.45+0.2%41
Moonshot HYPE SAR III sz2 10x SL8
HYPE · 4H · Long only
+34.9%2.41+0.1%41
ADA Momentum · Daily
ADA · Daily · Long/short
+166.0%0.84+3.8%37
ARB MACD Downtrend Short · 4H
ARB · 4H · Short only
+75.1%0.90−0.6%37
AVAX Momentum · Daily
AVAX · Daily · Long/short
+73.3%0.77+0.8%37
ENA Downtrend Short · 4H
ENA · 4H · Short only
+27.2%0.67+3.8%37
ENA Ethereum-Led Downtrend Short · 4H
ENA · 4H · Short only
+41.0%0.89+4.2%37
Ethereum MACD Momentum · 4H
ETH · 4H · Long only
+105.0%0.900.0%37
FARTCOIN Downtrend Short · 4H
FARTCOIN · 4H · Short only
+25.0%0.68+3.3%37
Gold Wide-Stop Momentum · Daily
GOLD · Daily · Long only
+40.9%0.30−6.2%37
Google Momentum · Daily
GOOGL · Daily · Long only
+47.2%0.39+1.2%37
HYPE Momentum · 4H
HYPE · 4H · Long only
+86.3%1.78−1.7%37
JUP Two-Way Momentum · 4H
JUP · 4H · Long/short
+34.0%0.77−4.2%37
NEAR Momentum · 4H
NEAR · 4H · Long/short
+33.6%0.41−3.7%37
Nvidia Momentum · Daily
NVDA · Daily · Long only
+93.6%0.64−0.7%37
OP Momentum · 4H
OP · 4H · Long/short
+25.9%0.65+0.5%37
PENDLE Downtrend Short · 4H
PENDLE · 4H · Short only
+24.8%0.51−7.3%37
PEPE Momentum · 4H
1000PEPE · 4H · Long/short
+35.7%0.51−7.4%37
S&P 500 Momentum · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+80.3%0.47−5.0%37
SEI Momentum · 4H
SEI · 4H · Long/short
+98.5%0.99+4.9%37
SEI Momentum · Daily
SEI · Daily · Long/short
+53.0%0.74+4.7%37
Silver Momentum · Daily
SILVER · Daily · Long only
+36.2%0.28−6.4%37
STX Adaptive Momentum · 4H
STX · 4H · Long/short
+68.3%0.88−9.7%37
STX Momentum · 4H
STX · 4H · Long/short
+37.9%0.61−1.7%37
STX Momentum · Daily
STX · Daily · Long/short
+35.2%0.62+4.1%37
TAO Momentum · 4H
TAO · 4H · Long only
+50.1%0.86−1.1%37
TRUMP MACD Downtrend Short · 4H
TRUMP · 4H · Short only
+38.8%0.99+22.8%37
UNI Breakdown Short · 4H
UNI · 4H · Short only
+60.0%0.66−5.6%37
VVV Momentum · 4H
VVV · 4H · Long only
+68.6%1.08−9.0%37
WLD Uncrowded Downtrend Short · 4H
WLD · 4H · Short only
+29.3%0.48−2.9%37
XLM Momentum · 4H
XLM · 4H · Long only
+28.9%0.450.0%37
XLM Momentum · Daily
XLM · Daily · Long/short
+119.4%0.80+3.0%37
ZEC Momentum · 4H
ZEC · 4H · Long only
+71.6%0.98−2.7%37
ZEC Momentum · Daily
ZEC · Daily · Long only
+113.6%0.90−1.3%37
HYPE · N10 Prop
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+106.1%2.39+0.2%18
HYPE - Apex Max SAR III 10X sz10 l20
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+903.4%2.320.0%9
Moonshot HYPE SAR III sz10 20x SL3.5
HYPE · 4H · Long only
+903.4%2.320.0%9
ADA Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
ADA · 4H · Long/short
+334.2%1.120.0%1
Apple MACD Zero Cross · Daily
AAPL · Daily · Long only
+159.2%0.880.0%1
ARB Calm Trend Scorecard · 4H
ARB · 4H · Long/short
+74.6%0.870.0%1
ARB Elder Impulse · Daily
ARB · Daily · Long/short
+72.7%0.640.0%1
ENA Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
ENA · 4H · Long/short
+119.8%1.65−0.2%1
HYPE MACD Histogram Rider · 4H
HYPE · 4H · Long/short
+59.2%1.07−1.6%1
NEAR Four-Indicator Vote · 4H
NEAR · 4H · Long/short
+215.7%0.88−0.5%1
PEPE Calm Trend Scorecard · 4H
1000PEPE · 4H · Long/short
+207.9%1.47+0.5%1
PEPE Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
1000PEPE · 4H · Long/short
+178.1%1.34+0.5%1
RENDER Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
RENDER · 4H · Long/short
+57.9%1.11+0.4%1
SEI Four-Indicator Vote · 4H
SEI · 4H · Long/short
+128.8%1.22−0.1%1
Solana Calm Trend Scorecard · 4H
SOL · 4H · Long/short
+169.1%1.00+0.1%1
Solana Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
SOL · 4H · Long/short
+172.0%0.91+0.1%1
STX Calm Trend Scorecard · 4H
STX · 4H · Long/short
+138.0%1.16−0.1%1
STX Four-Indicator Vote · 4H
STX · 4H · Long/short
+202.6%1.26−0.1%1
SUI Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
SUI · 4H · Long/short
+83.7%0.94−0.1%1
TRUMP Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
TRUMP · 4H · Long/short
+68.0%1.06+0.8%1
VVV Calm Trend Scorecard · 4H
VVV · 4H · Long/short
+70.9%1.34−2.0%1
WLD Composite Momentum Surge · 4H
WLD · 4H · Long/short
+158.7%1.33−0.6%1

Questions

How many MACD trading strategies does Trigr track?
101 published strategies, 81 of them built by Trigr. Each one has its own page, where its backtest and its live paper record are shown separately when it has them.
Do MACD trading strategies hold up live compared with their backtests?
Of the 79 with 14 or more days of live paper record, 38 are up (median 0.0%, average +0.3%, over a median 44 days). In backtest, 101 of 101 were up (median +72.7%, average +149.9%). The average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it. A backtest covers years and a live record covers weeks, so the two returns are not the same length of time.
What is MACD in a trading strategy?
MACD is the gap between a fast and a slow exponential moving average, with a signal line. Strategies trade its crosses and the turn of its histogram.

Keep exploring

MACD strategies by market

Other topics

Figures as of 2026-11-16, refreshed hourly. Backtests run on point-in-time market data with trading and builder fees included; the live paper record is simulated on live prices from the day a strategy is published and is not a funded account. A backtest covers years and a live record covers weeks, so the two returns are not the same length of time. See how backtests are run. Past performance, backtested or paper, does not guarantee future results. Nothing here is investment advice.