S&P 500 SMA strategies: backtest vs live results

An SMA (simple moving average) is the plain average of the last N closes, used as a trend line or a regime filter.

11 published strategies, 10 of them built by Trigr. Each one has its own page, where its backtest and its live paper record are shown separately when it has them. Of the 11 with 14 or more days of live paper record, 4 are up (median −0.3%, average 0.0%, over a median 106 days). In backtest, 11 of 11 were up (median +6.5%, average +25.7%). The average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it. A backtest covers years and a live record covers weeks, so the two returns are not the same length of time.

11 strategies
In backtest
11of 11 up
Median backtest return +6.5%, average +25.7%, over the years each backtest covers.
Live paper record · 14+ days
4of 11 up
Median live return −0.3%, average 0.0%, over a median 106 days. 7 down.

The median is the middle return. The average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it.

Backtest against live, strategy by strategy

One dot per strategy with 14 or more live days: how good its backtest looked, against what it has done since.

Live paper return
−5%−2.5%0%+2.5%+5%
Up liveDown live
00.511.52
Backtest Sharpe ratio

Live returns

How the 11 live paper returns are spread. Each record runs from the day its strategy was published, so they cover different lengths of time.

0
0
0
0
7
0
3
1
0
0
0
−20%−10%−5%−2%0%2%5%10%20%
UpFlat (0%)Down

Backtest and live results by indicator

Each row counts the strategies of one group: how many are up in backtest, and how many of those with a live record are up, flat or down since. The median is the middle return; the average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it.

Indicator
RSI6
2 of 6 (33%)
−0.2%−0.2%
Donchian Channel3
0 of 3
−0.6%−0.9%
Moving Average Crossover1
0 of 1
−0.6%−0.6%
UpFlat (0%)Down

Does a stronger backtest hold up live?

Grouped by the Sharpe ratio of the backtest: does the better-looking group do better live?

Backtest SharpeStrategiesUp liveMedian liveAvg live
under 0.59
3 of 9 (33%)
−0.3%−0.2%
0.5 to 12
1 of 2
+1.3%+1.3%
1 to 1.50
none yet
n/an/a
1.5 to 20
none yet
n/an/a
2 and over0
none yet
n/an/a

All 11 S&P 500 SMA strategies

Longest live record first, not best return first. Select a column to sort by it; open a strategy for its full record.

S&P 500 Breakout · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long/short
+4.9%0.32−0.4%106
S&P 500 Long-Hold Options Signal · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+6.5%0.35−0.1%106
S&P 500 Multi-Signal · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+7.4%0.42−0.6%106
S&P 500 Options Signal · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+5.7%0.31−0.4%106
S&P 500 Range Breakout · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long/short
+4.4%0.330.0%106
S&P 500 Short-Hold Options Signal · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long/short
+3.4%0.30−0.3%106
S&P 500 Small-Size Multi-Signal · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+5.6%0.41+0.2%106
S&P 500 Options-Led Multi-Signal · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+30.0%0.41+1.1%105
S&P 500 Trend Rider · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+19.1%0.42−1.6%105
SPX Tide MACross 50/200 sz10 · CORE5
SPX · Daily · Long/short
+12.9%0.66−0.6%41
S&P 500 Slow Dip Buyer · Daily
SPX · Daily · Long only
+183.2%0.66+3.1%37

Questions

How many S&P 500 SMA strategies does Trigr track?
11 published strategies, 10 of them built by Trigr. Each one has its own page, where its backtest and its live paper record are shown separately when it has them.
Do S&P 500 SMA strategies hold up live compared with their backtests?
Of the 11 with 14 or more days of live paper record, 4 are up (median −0.3%, average 0.0%, over a median 106 days). In backtest, 11 of 11 were up (median +6.5%, average +25.7%). The average adds every return, so a few very large ones move it. A backtest covers years and a live record covers weeks, so the two returns are not the same length of time.
What is SMA in a trading strategy?
An SMA (simple moving average) is the plain average of the last N closes, used as a trend line or a regime filter.

Keep exploring

More S&P 500 strategies

SMA on other markets

Figures as of 2026-11-16, refreshed hourly. Backtests run on point-in-time market data with trading and builder fees included; the live paper record is simulated on live prices from the day a strategy is published and is not a funded account. A backtest covers years and a live record covers weeks, so the two returns are not the same length of time. See how backtests are run. Past performance, backtested or paper, does not guarantee future results. Nothing here is investment advice.