A viral post said Bitcoin goes up 2x after McDonald's brings back the McRib. We put every McRib return since 2020 into Trigr, bought Bitcoin that day and held it for 30 days with fees. It worked once, in 2020, when everything went up. Six trades made +5.5% in total, while buying on November 1 with no sandwich made +26%. Verdict: fade it. Keep the sandwich.
The viral claim
The McRib is back on 27 October 2026. A post with more than 712,000 views shared a Bitcoin chart with every McRib return marked on it and said Bitcoin historically goes up more than 2x after the McRib returns. "Don't fade the McRib."
It is a joke, mostly. But a chart with arrows on it looks convincing, and some people will act on it. So we did what we do with every viral claim: we turned it into a rule and tested it with real fees.
How we rebuilt it in Trigr
There is no McRib data in Trigr, so we gave it the dates ourselves as a signal series: the day the McRib came back each year since 2020.
| Setting | Value |
|---|---|
| Market | Bitcoin |
| Signal | The day the McRib is back on the menu |
| Entry | Buy Bitcoin that day |
| Exit | Sell after 30 days |
| Test window | 2020 to 2025, six McRib returns |
| Costs | Fees included |
The results
| Year | McRib back | 30-day result |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 2 December | +54% |
| 2021 | 1 November | -7% |
| 2022 | 31 October | -20% |
| 2023 | 1 November | +9% |
| 2024 | 3 December | -2% |
| 2025 | 11 November | -13% |
| Total | 6 trades | +5.5% |
2020 was legendary: +54% in a month. But that was the year almost everything went up. After that, the McRib won once more in 2023 and lost in four of the five years. Add it all up and the indicator made +5.5% over six years.
A 2x claim and a +5.5% result are not close. The chart in the viral post only marks the dates. It does not show what happened in the weeks right after them, and that is the part that matters if you buy on the day.
The boring version
Most McRib returns happen around the start of November. So we asked a simpler question: what if you just bought Bitcoin on November 1 every year and held for 30 days, with no sandwich involved?
| Same 6 years, hold 30 days, fees in | Return |
|---|---|
| Buy on November 1 | +26% |
| Buy on McRib day | +5.5% |
The plain calendar date did almost five times better. Whatever edge the McRib seems to have, it looks like a November effect. Some people call it Uptober or Upvember, and that is probably all the chart was showing.
Six trades is also a tiny sample. One great year can carry the whole result, and here it did.
Why funny indicators look so good on charts
Charts like this work because of how we read them. You see arrows next to big green moves and your brain links the two. The years where the date came before a drop are on the chart too, but they are easy to skip.
Three checks catch most of these:
- Test the exact rule. Not "Bitcoin went up after the McRib at some point," but "buy on the day, sell after a fixed time, fees included."
- Compare it with a plain baseline. Here the baseline was the same month with no signal. If the baseline does as well or better, the signal adds nothing.
- Count the trades. Six trades cannot prove anything. Our guide to backtest overfitting warning signs explains why small samples fool people so often.
We used the same approach on the S&P 500 after midterm elections. That pattern was real, but the normal base rate explained most of it. The McRib is the same story with less data and more barbecue sauce.
What we would test next
If you want to take the joke further: try a longer hold such as 60 or 90 days, try selling when the McRib leaves the menu, and compare each with buying on the same date with no signal. We would bet on the calendar every time. For a rule built on news dates that did show a real bounce, see our test of doing the opposite of Peter Schiff.
Verdict: trade it or fade it?
Fade it. The McRib indicator worked once, in a year when everything went up. Over six years it made +5.5%, and plain November did far better. No edge found.
We are still getting the McRib though.
Try it yourself
You can test any indicator in Trigr, even the strange ones. Upload your own list of dates as a signal series and backtest it with fees in a few minutes. The Trigr docs explain how signal series and fees work. This is a research article: the rule runs on data we uploaded ourselves, so it is not listed as a strategy.
Sources: Wikipedia on the McRib and Wikipedia on calendar effects.
Backtest, not live. BTC daily, 2020 to 2025, six trades, 30-day hold, fees included. Research only. Past results are not a promise of future results, and this is not financial advice.